Dr. Michael Anthony opened the doors to Anthony Dental Care over 40 years ago on the square in Sunbury. Today, Dr. David Anthony continues the tradition of a patient-first practice model that delivers high-quality dental care while loving our patients and serving them with grace, kindness, and excellence. Our highly trained, compassionate, caring team makes it their mission to ensure you leave your appointment with a smile!
We’re proud to serve you and the Sunbury community with the same care we want and expect for our family. At Anthony Dental Care we:
Promise to always listen to your concerns and address your needs
Stay at the forefront of the dental industry
Embrace newly advanced procedures, materials, and technologies
Never compromise on aesthetics or results
Emphasize patient education and comfort
Pair the treatment you need with the compassion you deserve
Insurance at Our Sunbury Office
Our Sunbury office also accepts most PPO insurance plans, and we are in-network with many major providers. Please contact your insurance company to confirm that we accept your plan.
The most common insurance plans for our Sunbury patients include Aetna (INN), Delta Premier, Anthem, and Connections Dental. Many patients also use Delta, MetLife, Humana, and UnitedHealthcare (UHC) at this location.
If you don’t have dental insurance or if you prefer to pay directly, we offer flexible payment options and can discuss financing plans to fit your budget. Everyone deserves a healthy smile, and we’ll work with you to make treatment affordable.
Sunbury Insurance FAQs
Does the Sunbury office accept PPO dental insurance?
Yes. We accept most PPO insurance plans and are in-network with many major providers.
Which plans are most common for Sunbury patients?
The most common are Aetna (INN), Delta Premier, Anthem, and Connections Dental. Many patients also use Delta, MetLife, Humana, and UHC here.
Will you file my claim for me?
Yes. Our front desk team is happy to file claims and help you make the most of your benefits, whether your plan is in-network or out-of-network.
We invite your family to experience the Anthony Dental Care way and become a member of our dental family.
I love this place. Everyone is absolutely amazing, friendly, knowledgeable, helpful. I was getting implants at the Centerburg office and one of the staff members from Sunbury came to see the results. Very caring staff members 🫶 Perfect fit!!
Jenn Ford
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing feedback! It’s great to know that we’re giving the high level of care one would expect from a trusted oral healthcare provider.
Always a great experience at Anthony dental. I just love Dr Grandstaff. Went in for a routine cleaning, and they did a temporary fix on a crown I was having problems with, that I was sure I would have to make a separate appointment for. Always courteous and friendly.
Practice Response:
Thank you for taking the time to share these thoughts with us! We thrive on feedback!
I highly recommend. We moved from Sunbury to Groveport and still utilize Anthony Dental in Sunbury for all our dental needs. Professional, caring and affordable.
Practice Response:
We are here to care for and support our amazing patients! Thanks for sharing!
First time at Anthony Dental. Exceptional experience! Friendly and helpful staff at the front desk. Hygienist was excellent and took time to show me photos of areas of concern. Dr. Stern was very knowledgeable and friendly. So happy that I chose to come to this practice!
Practice Response:
We love seeing patients leave our office with a smile! Thanks for taking the time to review us.
Love Anthony dental. They’re always great at service, cleaning, and other needed services. My cleaning technician today was a wonderful giraffe 🦒 ☺️. It made for a happy Halloween.
Practice Response:
Thanks so much! We are happy we could provide an enjoyable experience at our office!
Had a dental emergency over the weekend, cracked tooth/filling.
Luckily they were able to book me first thing Monday morning. Everyone was completely helpful, understanding and gentle! They were able to fix the problem that day. Great staff!
Practice Response:
Thank you for writing a review! It’s such a pleasure to take care of all our wonderful patients!
I must say that my six-month checkup and cleaning were excellent. Brii, is such an awesome dental assistant! She’s always so knowledgeable and professional whenever I have a visit. This place is definitely a 10/10. Thank you for the great service…
Practice Response:
Thank you for leaving a review! We appreciate the kind words and continued support!
I have always had good care and friendly, helpful people at Anthony Dental.
Practice Response:
Thanks for writing us! We’re so glad to learn about positive experiences with our practice. We are dedicated to providing excellent care for each of our patients and we appreciate knowing when we exceed expectations.
I recently had a crown procedure, after putting it off for the last 6 years. Ive had the worst experiences with dentists, which is why I’ve delayed getting this tooth fixed. I found Anthony dental after my recent move and gave them a chance. I’m really glad i did. They were great! They handled… more »
I recently had a crown procedure, after putting it off for the last 6 years. Ive had the worst experiences with dentists, which is why I’ve delayed getting this tooth fixed. I found Anthony dental after my recent move and gave them a chance. I’m really glad i did. They were great! They handled my anxiety and fears, made me comfortable and relaxed and got me taken care of with minimal discomfort! I’m really happy with my experience, and had a great time! Hard to say a great time at a dentist, but they really did a wonderful job. Thank you!!
Practice Response:
Thank you for taking the time to share these thoughts with us! We thrive on feedback!
5-star service! The staff is professional, friendly, and efficient. I was taken back right on time, and the cleaning was top-notch. Great, honest dentists who don’t push unnecessary services. Efficient scheduling too!”
Practice Response:
Thanks so much! We are happy we could provide an enjoyable experience at our office!
We appreciate feedback! For any questions or concerns, don’t hesitate to reach out to us at (614) 983-3060. We’re here to help. Sincerely, The Anthony Dental Care Team
Anthony Dental Care could not have been more professional and caring from the time I walked in and was greeted to the time I left. Abbey cleaned my teeth and she was very friendly and professional. Abbey did a great job… I know they have many patients, my son is in the Marine Corps and Abbey… more »
Anthony Dental Care could not have been more professional and caring from the time I walked in and was greeted to the time I left. Abbey cleaned my teeth and she was very friendly and professional. Abbey did a great job… I know they have many patients, my son is in the Marine Corps and Abbey remembered that from the last time I was in (six months) he was getting deployed. She asked about my son and my wife and she was truly caring. I could not have left there being more satisfied and happy. Every time I go to Anthony Dental Care I leave very satisfied.
Practice Response:
Thank you for writing a review! It’s such a pleasure to take care of all our wonderful patients!
An outstanding experience at this dental office. The staff is incredibly welcoming, professional, and attentive from the moment you walk in. The dentist take the time to explain everything clearly and make sure you are comfortable throughout the entire procedure. The level of care and attention to… more »
An outstanding experience at this dental office. The staff is incredibly welcoming, professional, and attentive from the moment you walk in. The dentist take the time to explain everything clearly and make sure you are comfortable throughout the entire procedure. The level of care and attention to detail is exceptional. The office is clean, modern, and very well organized. I highly recommend this practice to anyone looking for top-quality dental care. Owner is also Christian.
Practice Response:
We love seeing patients leave our office with a smile! Thanks for taking the time to review us.
Always professional and polite as well as they do great work.
Practice Response:
Thanks for writing us! We’re so glad to learn about positive experiences with our practice. We are dedicated to providing excellent care for each of our patients and we appreciate knowing when we exceed expectations.
Anthony Dental Care is efficient, friendly, and professional. Even my 12-year-old relaxes in the dental chair, giggles, and smiles with clean teeth! I highly recommend this office, the doctors, and the staff!
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing. We always strive to provide the best oral health care possible!
Anthony Dental Care in Sunbury is by far the Best! The staff is always so kind and they are always so sweet to my lil kiddos and make sure they are relaxed and comfortable. I appreciate all their hard work.
Practice Response:
We appreciate all of our patients and are truly grateful for words of encouragement.
The receptionist at the front desk went over and above to help me. She was really nice. Also, one of the dentists told me a relatable story about a time that she felt the same way that I did a time in her life. The two of them made me feel more than just a patient. I was seen as a person before… more »
The receptionist at the front desk went over and above to help me. She was really nice. Also, one of the dentists told me a relatable story about a time that she felt the same way that I did a time in her life. The two of them made me feel more than just a patient. I was seen as a person before profit. They changed my entire experience. I’m experiencing a lot in my personal life… Those two ladies at the south high Street branch are exceptional and great at their jobs. They showed me that I was more than a forgettable number, I was a human not just another dollar sign to write off later. Thanks a lot!!!
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing feedback! It’s great to know that we’re giving the high level of care one would expect from a trusted oral healthcare provider.
Very kind courteous and thorough. Very pleasant experience
Practice Response:
Thanks for writing us! We’re so glad to learn about positive experiences with our practice. We are dedicated to providing excellent care for each of our patients and we appreciate knowing when we exceed expectations.
Excellent care. Great team of professionals. I had a dental emergency and they were able to get me in and take care of my issue the same day. Very much appreciated!
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing feedback! It’s great to know that we’re giving the high level of care one would expect from a trusted oral healthcare provider.
My hygienist is so supportive and caring. She explained all the problems and how we could work together to fix them.
Practice Response:
Thanks for writing us! We’re so glad to learn about positive experiences with our practice. We are dedicated to providing excellent care for each of our patients and we appreciate knowing when we exceed expectations.
I broke a tooth on Sunday, called Anthony Dental on Monday and they were able to fix my tooth on Tuesday. I couldn’t do better than that. As they worked, they explained what they were doing and were so pleasant and professional.
Practice Response:
Thanks for writing us! We’re so glad to learn about positive experiences with our practice. We are dedicated to providing excellent care for each of our patients and we appreciate knowing when we exceed expectations.
Heidi always does a wonderful job on my cleanings!
Recently I broke part of a tooth and filling in Tuscany. I emailed them and was able to make an appointment for 2 days after we got back. Dr. Stearn and his team were awesome! Got me in and out with a temporary crown and will have the permanent in… more »
Heidi always does a wonderful job on my cleanings!
Recently I broke part of a tooth and filling in Tuscany. I emailed them and was able to make an appointment for 2 days after we got back. Dr. Stearn and his team were awesome! Got me in and out with a temporary crown and will have the permanent in 4 days! This is an awesome practice!
This happened last year and it looks like I forgot to hit post🙄
Practice Response:
Thank you for leaving a review! We appreciate the kind words and continued support!
Always pleasant and professional. I’ve been a patient since the late 1970’s when the practice was on the town square. Reasonable prices too if you need more than a cleaning or filling. I highly recommend Anthony Dental.
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing. We always strive to provide the best oral health care possible!
Hygienist Elysa was quick, competent, yet thorough while working with me this morning. And, the dentist, I didn’t catch her name, was pleasant and also thorough, plus they both accommodated my scheduling dilemma for my
next appointment. Thank you, Anthony Dental.
Practice Response:
Thank you for leaving a review! We appreciate the kind words and continued support!
After moving out of sunbury I went to another dentist. The other practice took excellent care of me while I was away. We moved back to sunbury recently and so therefore I wanted to come back to a place where I was treated exceptionally well over the years. Thank you Anthony Dental for my welcome… more »
After moving out of sunbury I went to another dentist. The other practice took excellent care of me while I was away. We moved back to sunbury recently and so therefore I wanted to come back to a place where I was treated exceptionally well over the years. Thank you Anthony Dental for my welcome home.
Today I got my first cleaning after knee surgery! So wonderful to get my teeth cleaned! Very gentle and thorough!
Practice Response:
Thanks so much! We are happy we could provide an enjoyable experience at our office!
This dental office was recommended by a friend from my church. My father in law is a dentist and he retired at 82! We were struggling to find a new dentist that wouldn’t force procedures on us. I could not be happier with Anthony Dental. SUPER friendly staff and care seems good ( we only had a… more »
This dental office was recommended by a friend from my church. My father in law is a dentist and he retired at 82! We were struggling to find a new dentist that wouldn’t force procedures on us. I could not be happier with Anthony Dental. SUPER friendly staff and care seems good ( we only had a teeth cleaning). We will definitely be back!
Practice Response:
We love seeing patients leave our office with a smile! Thanks for taking the time to review us.
Very professional and friendly! I totally appreciate how they explain what they’re doing.
Practice Response:
Thanks for writing us! We’re so glad to learn about positive experiences with our practice. We are dedicated to providing excellent care for each of our patients and we appreciate knowing when we exceed expectations.
The oxymoronic phrase “great trip to the dentist” is what Anthony Dental is all about.. Staff is polite, helpful and interested. They integrate technology into the practice in very interesting and patient friendly ways. It must be a great place to work as there is very low staff turnover…. more »
The oxymoronic phrase “great trip to the dentist” is what Anthony Dental is all about.. Staff is polite, helpful and interested. They integrate technology into the practice in very interesting and patient friendly ways. It must be a great place to work as there is very low staff turnover. I’ve been a patient there since the late 20th century! Need great dental care? Anthony won’t disappoint.
Addendum: six month later 9/24, all of the above still holds true and then some!
Addendum: It is now 4/26. I’ve been there every six months- and the practice keeps improving. Great people. Up to date technology and a very positive atmosphere.
Practice Response:
Thank you for taking the time to share these thoughts with us! We thrive on feedback!
I always have a great experience at Anthony Dental . They’ve cared for my families oral health for 8 years. My dental hygienist is exceptional. She’s incredibly thorough , gentle and always makes sure I’m comfortable throughout every visit. Her attention to detail and genuine care truly… more »
I always have a great experience at Anthony Dental . They’ve cared for my families oral health for 8 years. My dental hygienist is exceptional. She’s incredibly thorough , gentle and always makes sure I’m comfortable throughout every visit. Her attention to detail and genuine care truly set her apart . I leave with my teeth feeling amazing and a clear understanding of how to keep them healthy .
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing. We always strive to provide the best oral health care possible!
Always very prompt, friendly and professional with a comfortable space for everyone without feeling cramped. Scheduling is super easy with a lot of flexibility. Cleaning was very detailed AND gentle. Love this place for so many reasons!
Practice Response:
Thanks for writing us! We’re so glad to learn about positive experiences with our practice. We are dedicated to providing excellent care for each of our patients and we appreciate knowing when we exceed expectations.
Consistently great experience with knowledgeable caring staff. Have been a customer for years and experienced natural staff rotation. Quality has remained consistently good.
Practice Response:
We are here to care for and support our amazing patients! Thanks for sharing!
The staff is very attentive and helpful. Madison was my hygienist and was very nice. She explained everything and did a great job. All of my options were well explained by the Dentist. Would highly recommend this office.
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing feedback! It’s great to know that we’re giving the high level of care one would expect from a trusted oral healthcare provider.
From the moment you walk through the door till your appointment is done, all the staff are warm, welcoming, and professional.
Practice Response:
Thanks for writing us! We’re so glad to learn about positive experiences with our practice. We are dedicated to providing excellent care for each of our patients and we appreciate knowing when we exceed expectations.
My denture had to be repaired and refitted. When I left there, it fit perfectly. I love the dentists and the staff. They are all so friendly and helpful.
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing feedback! It’s great to know that we’re giving the high level of care one would expect from a trusted oral healthcare provider.
My first experience here was great! Jennifer and Danielle at the front desk are welcoming and very friendly. Brii did an amazing job cleaning my teeth. No pain or discomfort. Thank you Dr. Paxton and staff for a extremely thorough and informative visit.
Practice Response:
Thanks so much! We are happy we could provide an enjoyable experience at our office!
They are always fast and friendly, and I’m very comfortable going there. I’m usually seen right away with no long wait. I also love the convenience of booking my next appointment with my dental hygienist before I leave.
Practice Response:
We love seeing patients leave our office with a smile! Thanks for taking the time to review us.
Welcoming office and staff. Friendly and thorough hygienist. Professional and knowledgeable Dentist.
Practice Response:
Thanks for writing us! We’re so glad to learn about positive experiences with our practice. We are dedicated to providing excellent care for each of our patients and we appreciate knowing when we exceed expectations.
Great dental practice! Everyone is extremely friendly and the culture of the entire office is awesome. And…they explain thoroughly each dental procedure.
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing. We always strive to provide the best oral health care possible!
I received a sufficient number of appointment reminders which I found helpful. My appointment started on time, was completed in a reasonable amount of time and received great care. The office is set up and ran efficiently and all staff I interacted with were very professional, helpful and friendly…. more »
I received a sufficient number of appointment reminders which I found helpful. My appointment started on time, was completed in a reasonable amount of time and received great care. The office is set up and ran efficiently and all staff I interacted with were very professional, helpful and friendly. Scheduling is easy. They are very busy so a rescheduled appointment was pushed out 3 months but I was able get in earlier (1 month) as I opted to be put on their cancellation call list. I am very pleased with the care I received and Anthony Dental Care over all!
Practice Response:
Thank you for leaving a review! We appreciate the kind words and continued support!
We believe in a patient-centered approach to dental care. What does that mean? It means that we talk with you. We practice dentistry in the best interest of our patient’s health.