Sunbury Location

Dr. Michael Anthony opened the doors to Anthony Dental Care over 40 years ago on the square in Sunbury. Today, Dr. David Anthony continues the tradition of a patient-first practice model that delivers high-quality dental care while loving our patients and serving them with grace, kindness, and excellence. Our highly trained, compassionate, caring team makes it their mission to ensure you leave your appointment with a smile! 

We’re proud to serve you and the Sunbury community with the same care we want and expect for our family. At Anthony Dental Care we:

  • Promise to always listen to your concerns and address your needs
  • Stay at the forefront of the dental industry
  • Embrace newly advanced procedures, materials, and technologies
  • Never compromise on aesthetics or results
  • Emphasize patient education and comfort
  • Pair the treatment you need with the compassion you deserve

Insurance at Our Sunbury Office

Our Sunbury office also accepts most PPO insurance plans, and we are in-network with many major providers. Please contact your insurance company to confirm that we accept your plan.

The most common insurance plans for our Sunbury patients include Aetna (INN), Delta Premier, Anthem, and Connections Dental. Many patients also use Delta, MetLife, Humana, and UnitedHealthcare (UHC) at this location.

If you don’t have dental insurance or if you prefer to pay directly, we offer flexible payment options and can discuss financing plans to fit your budget. Everyone deserves a healthy smile, and we’ll work with you to make treatment affordable.

Sunbury Insurance FAQs

We invite your family to experience the Anthony Dental Care way and become a member of our dental family. 

740-965-4090

257 W Granville St,
Sunbury, Ohio 43074

OUR REVIEWS FROM SUNBURY

Sunbury Review Summary

5   2313
4   34
3   4
2   0
1   0
161 reviews with no rating
5.0
2512 reviews
5 on Google, Mar 19, 2026
Whitney was awesome!
Practice Response:
Thank you for taking the time to share these thoughts with us! We thrive on feedback!
5 on Google, Mar 19, 2026
Consistently great experience with knowledgeable caring staff. Have been a customer for years and experienced natural staff rotation. Quality has remained consistently good.
Practice Response:
We are here to care for and support our amazing patients! Thanks for sharing!
5 on Google, Mar 18, 2026
Great people. Always sure that you are comfortable no matter what procedure you are having
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing. We always strive to provide the best oral health care possible!
5 on Google, Mar 17, 2026
Always excellent care. Thanks so much!
Practice Response:
We appreciate all of our patients and are truly grateful for words of encouragement.
5 on Google, Mar 16, 2026
Timely, professional and just plain nice people.
Practice Response:
Thank you for leaving a review! We appreciate the kind words and continued support!
5 on Google, Mar 16, 2026
They are knowledgeable, quick and friendly They explain things well which puts you at ease. They take good care of your teeth and you. .
Practice Response:
Thank you for writing a review! It’s such a pleasure to take care of all our wonderful patients!
5 on Google, Mar 14, 2026
Great place
Practice Response:
Thanks so much! We are happy we could provide an enjoyable experience at our office!
5 on Google, Mar 12, 2026
Practice Response:
Thank you for leaving a review! Our team aims to provide exemplary care for all of our amazing patients.
5 on Google, Mar 12, 2026
The staff is very attentive and helpful. Madison was my hygienist and was very nice. She explained everything and did a great job. All of my options were well explained by the Dentist. Would highly recommend this office.
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing feedback! It’s great to know that we’re giving the high level of care one would expect from a trusted oral healthcare provider.
5 on Google, Mar 12, 2026
From the moment you walk through the door till your appointment is done, all the staff are warm, welcoming, and professional.
Practice Response:
Thanks for writing us! We’re so glad to learn about positive experiences with our practice. We are dedicated to providing excellent care for each of our patients and we appreciate knowing when we exceed expectations.
5 on Google, Mar 11, 2026
Great as always!!! Everyone is friendly and professional! I love it there! I have recommended family and friends!
Practice Response:
We love seeing patients leave our office with a smile! Thanks for taking the time to review us.
5 on Google, Mar 11, 2026
Practice Response:
A positive review like this one really makes our day! Thanks for spreading the word!
5 on Google, Mar 10, 2026
Practice Response:
Thank you for leaving a review! Our team aims to provide exemplary care for all of our amazing patients.
5 on Google, Mar 10, 2026
Practice Response:
Thank you for leaving a review! Our team aims to provide exemplary care for all of our amazing patients.
5 on Google, Mar 10, 2026
They were awesome!
Practice Response:
Thank you for leaving a review! We appreciate the kind words and continued support!
5 on Google, Mar 09, 2026
My denture had to be repaired and refitted. When I left there, it fit perfectly. I love the dentists and the staff. They are all so friendly and helpful.
Practice Response:
Thank you for sharing feedback! It’s great to know that we’re giving the high level of care one would expect from a trusted oral healthcare provider.
5 on Google, Mar 09, 2026
Anthony Dental Care is the best!. An incredible team and the dental care is top notch!
Practice Response:
Thank you for writing a review! It’s such a pleasure to take care of all our wonderful patients!
5 on Google, Mar 09, 2026
Practice Response:
Thank you so much for letting us know how it went!
5 on Google, Mar 08, 2026
My first experience here was great! Jennifer and Danielle at the front desk are welcoming and very friendly. Brii did an amazing job cleaning my teeth. No pain or discomfort. Thank you Dr. Paxton and staff for a extremely thorough and informative visit.
Practice Response:
Thanks so much! We are happy we could provide an enjoyable experience at our office!
5 on Google, Mar 07, 2026
They are always fast and friendly, and I’m very comfortable going there. I’m usually seen right away with no long wait. I also love the convenience of booking my next appointment with my dental hygienist before I leave.
Practice Response:
We love seeing patients leave our office with a smile! Thanks for taking the time to review us.

Schedule Your Visit

We believe in a patient-centered approach to dental care. What does that mean? It means that we talk with you. We practice dentistry in the best interest of our patient’s health.

Comforted by the staff. Practical and solid advice from Dr. Bookwalter. Considerate of my age and condition.

Maria G

I love going to get my teeth cleaned! Especially when you have wonderful folks like those at Anthony dental care.

Dani W

Associations & Memberships

We’re proud to be affiliated with the following organizations:

Scroll to Top